Readership, it is with a heavy heart that I must inform you that I have canceled my order for the MacBook Air. Please, allow me to elaborate.
At home I have a 17″ iMac G5. This machine is three years old and is showing its age. It is fully functional but can be slow at times. The display is usable, but small. The inability to expand the internal components has never hindered, but storage is getting tight and my only option is to go external. I had always intended on replacing this machine this year and the MacBook Air would be no replacement–it would be a supplement.
I am saddened by coming to this realization. The light weight of the MacBook Air is incredibly appealing. Going between work, home, school, and elsewhere without a notebook has been difficult, and my desire to carry around a 5 or 6 pound machine has been next to none. Granted, my only option at this point is to carry around a 5 or 6 pound machine running Microsoft Windows but still: the OS will not make the notebook any lighter.
The small size of the Air would have also equaled room for another couple of shirts in the saddlebags of my motorcycle, perfect for a weekend trip out of the city. Any review I’ve read suggested that the Air removes the question as to whether to bring your notebook with you, and that’s exactly the kind of notebook that I’ve been waiting for. Even as I write this I am again thinking that the MacBook Air is the one for me.
Enter my more reasonable self, and prepare for another shocker as I admit that I probably cannot afford to buy a $2000 paper-thin notebook and a new desktop machine this year. Take a minute to soak that one in because I actually said it (wrote it).
So here’s the situation: I have all of my money and Apple has none. Apple has released the MacBook Air, has recently updated the Mac Pro, is expected to update the MacBook Pro in a few weeks, and is mid-cycle on the MacBook (updates for the June education buying season, no doubt). Here is what I’m considering:
- Buy a Mac Pro–a tower of 8-core power–and an external display (22″ seems to be the sweet-spot, price wise, right now. Supplement this with a MacBook after the next refresh to support my portable side. Approximate Apple cost: $4149 (plus taxes).
- Buy a MacBook Pro after the update and an external display. At home I can continue to use the Bluetooth mouse and keyboard I own and I can “pseudo-dock” the machine while I’m at home. Approximate Apple cost: $2200 (plus taxes).
Because my desktop computer is only ever in use when I’m home, it is reasonable for me to have only the MacBook Pro, leaving no machine available at home when I’m out. The MacBook Pro is about as portable as the MacBook, being approximately 10% larger by weight and volume. The ideal situation would be a Mac Pro at home, with a MacBook Air on the road, a costly $4800 scenario.
Looking purely at the numbers the choice may be obvious, but any option is an investment that will, hopefully, last me another three years. My iMac, when I bought it, cost me a little over $2000–further evidence toward my limiting my spending to approximately that amount. Maybe I’ll just have to spring for larger saddlebags.
I welcome comments. And don’t forget, I can always re-order the Air if it turns out this was a mistake.